The Great Debate

[greedyneedygirl 4,156]

'Up or Under?' That is the question! Also in some Hotels that I have stayed at, the loo roll is kind of tucked and folded...

[mickymoist 3,513]

B all day long!  Anywhere I sit on a toilet and see A I am compelled to change it 😄

[Hidengo 277]

B is the only orientation that makes sense from an ergonomics perspective. A is acceptable only if you have a cat. 
 

No I am not arguing this point, neither will I accept any constructive criticism. 

[LovesToWet 3,802]

B

[Bacardi 10,134]

I am pro however it makes it into the toilet paper holder lol. It doesn't particularly matter to me which way it hangs. As long as it's there for me to wipe with! 

[Kupar 13,340]

B. Just B. 

[thisguy20 937]

Definitely "B": much easier to grasp the edge.

[Peewee123 1,124]

B is the only way!

[HitEmAll 1,066]

B. I'd classify people that prefer A as having a mental disorder 😂

[MaxWasTaken 522]

I allways change it to A to mess with people xD.

[Wolfpee 329]

B for sure.

[Remi 1,034]

B all the way.

[WantonLee 861]

When ever I see a toilet roll in orientation "A", I have the urge to change it to the better.

Or the worse, if I am only there for a number 1. >:)

But usually I do not dare doing that, first out of respect for the next... user (especially if there is no replacement roll present, and second because I did not wanna get caught.

 

But it is tempting... . 🙂

[Dr.P 1,473]

I choose B. I had cats, for many years, and they very rarely messed with the t.p. A kitten might do it, once.

[GenericUsername 1,108]

B always

[Alfresco 11,633]

Definitely B.  And I do sometimes correct it if someone has mistakenly installed it as A.

Based on the feedback here so far, B has got to be correct.  

The next question is: Do you think the situation illustrated in the first picture above is:

(C) A great attempt at providing a solution to both those who prefer (A) and those who prefer (B) - i.e. you can select from your chosen roll - OR

(D) a major issue because you would always want both rolls to be set the same, even if it weren't in your chosen style?

Personally I am with B and D.   I am just a little OCD and I find it a little "wrong" to have one roll one way and one the opposite.   Even though I would choose B all day long, I'd rather see two rolls configured as A than one A and one B on the same dispenser.

[Kupar 13,340]

1 minute ago, Alfresco said:

Definitely B.  And I do sometimes correct it if someone has mistakenly installed it as A.

Based on the feedback here so far, B has got to be correct.  

The next question is: Do you think the situation illustrated in the first picture above is:

(C) A great attempt at providing a solution to both those who prefer (A) and those who prefer (B) - i.e. you can select from your chosen roll - OR

(D) a major issue because you would always want both rolls to be set the same, even if it weren't in your chosen style?

Personally I am with B and D.   I am just a little OCD and I find it a little "wrong" to have one roll one way and one the opposite.   Even though I would choose B all day long, I'd rather see two rolls configured as A than one A and one B on the same dispenser.

Hmm ... I'd say C. I'm cool with it really 🙂 

[Shrek91 5]

I have 3cats and have B. Cat liter tray is under stairs and cats dont have access to toilet. 

[DoctorDoctor 1,391]

B, unless you are a cat owner.

[1badboy 581]

I just put a new roll in the bathroom.  B for sure!

[greedyneedygirl 4,156]

A...and I have a dog who likes to grab them and chew them up. Fascinating response BTW thanks to all! 

[watchr12 1,476]

From the U.S. patent application, December 22, 1891:

[Peeing4fun 23]

However it's positioned in my hand after I pick it up is how it's going on to the roller.  

[Ms. Tito 2,396]

B, all the way.

[Peewee123 1,124]

On 5/10/2022 at 4:11 PM, Alfresco said:

Personally I am with B and D.   I am just a little OCD and I find it a little "wrong" to have one roll one way and one the opposite.   Even though I would choose B all day long, I'd rather see two rolls configured as A than one A and one B on the same dispenser.

Exactly the same with all you said!